Team Members:
Bethany Frid
Michelle Thompson
Natalie Tran 
Concepts of Biology #107
Dr. Benjamin Aronson
University of Redlands

  Introduction     Materials and Methods     Research     Discussion

 

Results

BACILLUS CEREUS

Objective: The objective of this experiment was to find if Ortho Home Defense effected the growth of Bacillus Cereus.

The results of the pesticide's effect on bacteria were recorded by the number of colonies that survived in each condition which were then compared. The results are as follows:

            Test with Pesticide               

( # of colonies)

Test without Pesticide

( # of colonies)

172 298
285 319
284 285
287 300
293 241
240 349
Average: 260.1667 Average: 298.667
Variance: 1860.472 Variance: 1076.889
Standard Deviation: 43.133 Standard Deviation: 32.8

          P= 0.033 x 2 = .066

Must accept null hypothesis: Ortho Home Defense does not effect growth of Bacillus Cereus


       

                                                                              
                                                                                     
 

Discussion: This experiment shows slight decrease in the population of the bacteria exposed to Ortho Home Defense.  However, after doing statistical analysis, we found that the evidence was not strong enough to support the hypothesis that Ortho Home Defense adversely effects Bacillus Cereus.  Therefore the null hypothesis must be accepted: Ortho Home Defense does not effect growth of Bacillus Cereus.

DROSOPHILA MELANOGASTER

PART A-

Objective: The objective of this experiment was to find if Ortho Home Defense effected the survival rate of Drosophila melanogaster.

The effect of pesticide on fruit flies was measured by the mortality rate of  flies when their food source is exposed to Ortho-Home Defense compared to flies with an unaffected food source. The results as follows are the results of the original test simply comparing whether of not the flies were affected.

Without Pesticide With Pesticide
10 0
9 0
7 0
Average: 8.67 Average: 0
Variance: 1.5556 Variance: 0
Standard Deviation: 1.2472 Standard Deviation: 0

 

Females Without Pesticide Females Without Pesticide
5 0
7 0
3 0
Average: 5 Average: 0
Variance: 2.667 Variance: 0
Standard Deviation: 1.633 Standard Deviation: 0

     

Males Without Pesticide Males With Pesticide
5 0
2 0
4 0
Average: 3.6667 Average: 0
Variance: 13.998 Variance: 0
Standard Deviation: 3.74 Standard Deviation: 0

 

 

   

Discussion: Through this experiment it was made obvious that the presence of Ortho Home Defense adversely effected the survival rate of Drosophila melanogaster.  None of the flies exposed to Ortho Home Defense survived, while the flies not exposed to Ortho Home defense had a survival rate of 62%.  Therefore the hypothesis that Ortho Home Defense adversely effects the survival rate of Drosophila melanogaster is accepted.                                      

PART B-

Objective: The objective of this experiment was to find if a diluted solution of Ortho-Home defense would have as drastic effect on the flies as the regular strength, and to also find out if there was a dose that the flies could be exposed to and still live, and what that dose was.  We set up the experiment in increments where we tested five different dilutions of the pesticide mixed with water trying to find out if there is a safe amount of Ortho-Home Defense that can be consumed by the fruit flies. The increments are:

Water (in mL) Pesticide (in mL)
12.5 2.5
10 5
7.5 7.5
5 10
2.5 12.5
15 0
0 0

In each condition we added eighteen flies, nine boys and nine girls. We had a 0% survival rate for every test that involved pesticide exposure.  In the vile containing no pesticide, 6 out of the 9 boys survived and 9 out of the 9 girls survived.  The survival rate for the control group was approximately 83%.

Girls Survived Boys Survived
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
9 6

Discussion: None of the objectives of this experiments were achieved.  No dose was found that Drosophila melanogaster could be exposed to and still survive.  That, however, does not prove that it does not exist, only that we did not try a small enough dose.  The results of this experiment do show, however, that Drosophila melanogaster are quite sensitive to exposure to Ortho Home Defense and survival rates are definitely adversely effected, even at relatively low doses.

PART C-

Objective: The objective of this experiment was to find if exposure to an incredibly diluted dose of Ortho Home Defense to Drosophila melanogaster (1st) adults that were to become parents, and (2nd) to the offspring during all stages of development would adversely effect survival rates of the offspring.

Results:

With Water With Pesticide
108 90
144 139
138 96
69 108
132 136
164 106
Average: 125.833 flies Average: 112.5 flies
Variance: 920.1389 Variance: 349.2083
Standard Deviation: 30.3338 Standard Deviation: 18.68712

P= 0.149 x 2 = 0.298

Null hypothesis must be accepted: Ortho Home Defense does not effect survival rates of offspring

Discussion: The results of this experiment do show a slight decrease in survival rates of the those who were (and parents were) exposed to Ortho Home Defense.  However, after doing statistical analysis we found that the evidence was not strong enough to support the hypothesis that Ortho Home Defense adversely effects the survival rates of Drosophila melanogaster whose parents were exposed to Ortho Home Defense, and who they themselves where exposed to Ortho Home Defense during all stages of development.  Therefore, the null hypothesis must be accepted: Ortho Home Defense does not effect survival rates of Drosophila melanogaster whose parents were exposed to Ortho Home Defense, and who they themselves where exposed to Ortho Home Defense during all stages of development.

RADISHES AND BEANS

Objective: The objective of this experiment was to find if and how Ortho Home Defense effected germination and growth of Burpee Stringless Seeds and Radish Seeds.

Results are as follows:

Radishes in Water Radishes in Pesticide
Germinated Seeds: 12/12 Germinated Seeds: 8/12
Rate of Germination: 100% Rate of Germination: 66.7%
Seeds with Shoots: 4/12 Seeds with Shoots: 8/12
Rate of Shoots: 33.33% Rate of Shoots: 66.67%
Seeds with Leaves: 3/12 Seeds with Leaves: 8/12
Rate of Leaves: 25% Rate of Leaves: 66.7%

 

Beans in Water Beans in Pesticide
Germinated Seeds: 11/12 Germinated Seeds: 8/12
Rate of Germination: 91.7% Rate of Germination: 66.7%
Seeds with Shoots: 0/12 Seeds with Shoots: 0/12
Rate of Shoots: 0% Rate of Shoots: 0%
Seeds with Leaves: 0/12 Seeds with Leaves: 0/12
Rate of Leaves: 0% Rate of Leaves: 0%

                                                                  
                                Radishes with water                                  Radishes with pesticide

                   Radishes: Number of Shoots                             Radishes: Shoot Length

                       P = 0.084 x 2 = 0.168                                       P = 0.113 x 2 = 0.226

Null hypothesis must be accepted: Ortho Home Defense does             Null hypothesis must be accepted: Ortho Home   effect the number of shoots in radishes.                                              Defense does not effect the shoot length of radishes.

Water

With Pesticide

0

0

0

1

0

0

1

1

1

1

0

1

0

1

0

1

0

1

1

0

0

1

1

0

Average: <1

Average: <1

Variance: 0.2222

Variance: 0.2222

Standard Deviation: .4714

Standard Deviation: .4714

Water

With Pesticide

0 cm

0 cm

0 cm

.4 cm

0 cm

0 cm

.6 cm

.5 cm

.5 cm

.5 cm

0 cm

.4 cm

0 cm

.4 cm

0 cm

.4 cm

0 cm

.4 cm

.4 cm

0 cm

0 cm

.3 cm

.3 cm

0 cm

Average: 0.15 cm

Average: 0.275

Variance: 0.038956

Variance: 0.0402

Standard Deviation: 0.19738

Standard Deviation: 0.2005

                   

                                     

                                               

 

                   

                                    

                     

 

 

           Radish: Number of Roots                                                   Radishes: Root Length

                 P = 0.084 x 2 = 0.168                                                          P = 0.000

Null hypothesis must be accepted: Ortho Home Defense does           Null hypothesis must be rejected: Ortho Home Defense does not effect number of roots on radishes.                                                    effect root length of radishes.

Water

With Pesticide

1

0

1

1

1

0

1

1

1

1

1

1

1

1

1

1

1

1

1

0

1

1

1

0

Average : 1

Average: <1

Variance: 0

Variance: 0.222

Standard Deviation: 0

Standard Deviation: 0.4714

Water

With Pesticide

13 cm

0 cm

11 cm

1.5 cm

3 cm

0 cm

13 cm

1.4 cm

10.5 cm

1.6 cm

8.5 cm

1.7 cm

5 cm

2.1 cm

5.25 cm

0.9 cm

3 cm

1.4 cm

9 cm

0 cm

2 cm

0.9 cm

6.5 cm

0 cm

Average: 7.4792 cm

Average: 0.9583

Variance: 14.0047

Variance: 0.5606

Standard Deviation: 3.742

Standard Deviation: 0.749

                               

       

                   

 

 

 

                               

 

 

                                                              

                      Radishes: Number of Leaves

                             P= 0.042 x 2 = .084

Null hypothesis must be accepted: Ortho Home Defense does not                                                                                     effect the number of leaves in radishes.

Water

With Pesticide

0

0

0

2

0

0

2

2

2

2

0

2

0

2

0

2

0

2

2

0

0

2

0

0

Average: <1

Average: 1.3333

Variance: 0.750

Variance: 0.8888

Standard Deviation: 0.8660

Standard Deviation: 0.9427

                   

                                    

                                         

 

                        

      

 

 

 

 

  Burpee Stringless Beans: Number of Roots                Burpee Stringless Beans: Root Length

            P = 0.042  x 2 = .084                                                           P = 0.92 x 2 = 1.84

Null hypothesis must be accepted: Ortho Home Defense               Null hypothesis must be accepted: Ortho Home Defense does not effect number or roots in beans.                                       does not effect root length in beans.

Water

With Pesticide

1

1

1

0

1

0

1

0

1

1

1

0

0

1

1

1

9

1

5

1

1

1

10

1

Average: 2.6667

Average: <1

Variance: 10.7222

Variance: 0.2222

Standard Deviation: 3.274

Standard Deviation: 0.4714

Water

With Pesticide

2.3 cm

.5 cm

1.1 cm

0 cm

1.0 cm

0 cm

1.4 cm

0 cm

.9 cm

.7 cm

.4 cm

0 cm

0 cm

2.2 cm

1.1 cm

.8 cm

4.7 cm

1.2 cm

4.6 cm

1.4 cm

.5 cm

3.35 cm

3.8 cm

1.3 cm

Average: 1.8167 cm

Average: 0.9542 cm

Variance: 2.5008

Variance: 0.9673

Standard Deviation: 1.5814

Standard Deviation: 0.9835

        

                                   

  

                                    

 



 

 

 

 

           

Discussion: For radishes exposed to Ortho Home Defense there was a decrease in number of roots, and root length.  However, there was an increase seen in number of shoots, shoot length, and number of leaves.  After doing statistical analysis, however, we found that the evidence was not strong enough to support the hypothesis that Ortho Home Defense effects anything except root length.  We found that Ortho Home Defense does not effect number of roots, number of shoots, shoot length, or the number of leaves.  However, Ortho Home Defense does adversely effect root length.

For Burpee Stringless Beans exposed to Ortho Home Defense there was decrease in the number of roots as well as root length.  However, after doing statistical analysis we found that the evidence was not strong enough to support the hypothesis that Ortho Home Defense effects Burpee Stringless Bean germination and growth.  Therefore, Ortho Home Defense does not effect germination or growth of Burpee Stringless Beans.

 

 

 

 

 

 


Date of last update: 12/09/2004


University of Redlands Home Page